Bayindir heroics as Man Utd knock out Arsenal on penalties - player ratings
NewsSunday, 12 January 2025 at 19:33
Manchester United secured their spot in the FA Cup fourth round with a dramatic penalty shootout victory over Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium.
Bruno Fernandes opened the scoring for United, finishing off a brilliant assist from Alejandro Garnacho. However, Diogo Dalot’s second yellow card just after the hour mark left United a man down, and Arsenal capitalized to equalize through Gabriel Magalhães.
Arsenal were awarded a controversial penalty with 20 minutes remaining, but Altay Bayindir made a crucial save to deny Martin Ødegaard.
With neither side able to find a winner in extra time, the match was decided by penalties. Bayindir’s save from Kai Havertz gave United the edge, and the visitors converted all five of their penalties to secure victory.
Here are the player ratings from United's hard-fought win:
Player Ratings
Altay Bayindir – 9
A mixed start with some shaky goal kicks, but Bayindir redeemed himself with a crucial penalty save and excellent stops against Declan Rice. His heroics in the shootout sealed United’s progression.
Matthijs de Ligt – 8
Solid in defense, commanding in aerial battles, and unfortunate to deflect Magalhães’ shot into the net. His goal-line clearance in extra time was vital.
Harry Maguire – 8
Dominant against Arsenal’s aerial threats and made several crucial interventions. Unfairly penalized for a non-existent foul on Kai Havertz.
Lisandro Martínez – 8
Displayed his usual grit and determination. Harshly booked but put his body on the line in a composed and disciplined display.
Noussair Mazraoui – 8
Started the game cautiously but grew into his role with a diligent defensive performance. Adapted well after switching flanks with Dalot.
Manuel Ugarte – 7
Provided strength and composure in midfield, executing Amorim’s tactical instructions effectively. A physical presence throughout the match.
Kobbie Mainoo – 6
Had a quiet game but showed promise alongside Ugarte in midfield. Taken off in the 81st minute after a solid shift.
Diogo Dalot – 4
A disappointing performance. Recklessly gave away fouls, leading to his red card for two clumsy challenges.
Bruno Fernandes – 8
Scored a superb opener and led by example in the shootout, converting his penalty with composure. Booked for frustration at a refereeing decision but remained influential.
Alejandro Garnacho – 7
Struggled to adapt early on but came alive with a brilliant assist for Fernandes. Worked hard defensively and put in a good shift.
Rasmus Højlund – 4
Failed to make an impact and struggled to hold up the ball. A disappointing outing for the forward.
Substitutes
Amad – 8
Injected creativity off the bench, setting up two chances for Zirkzee and providing an attacking spark when United needed it.
Joshua Zirkzee – 8
Showed determination and nearly scored from one of Amad’s setups. Kept his cool to convert the winning penalty.
Toby Collyer – 7
Brought on for energy and stability in midfield. Contributed effectively in extra time.
Tyrell Malacia – 7
Made an important tackle on Raheem Sterling shortly after coming on. Solid defensively.
Leny Yoro – 8
Came on in extra time and showed maturity beyond his years. Took his penalty with great confidence.
Manager: Ruben Amorim – 8
Amorim’s decisions were measured and logical throughout the match. His substitutions were well-timed, and his side’s organization after Dalot’s red card was commendable.
Summary
United showed grit and determination to overcome adversity and keep their FA Cup defense alive. With standout performances from Bayindir, Fernandes, and the substitutes, United fans will hope this win is a sign of better days ahead under Amorim’s leadership.
