Ex-Man Utd fullback Álvaro Carreras flying at Real Madrid is what Reds need

Manchester United fans have been left reflecting on another academy prospect who slipped through the net after former youth player Álvaro Carreras completed a high-profile transfer to Real Madrid — and has made an instant impact.

The 22-year-old Spanish left-back joined Madrid this summer from Benfica in a deal worth around €50 million, returning to the club where he began his youth career.

His stunning debut — capped by a long-range strike that “defied physics”, has reignited debate among United supporters about the club’s handling of young talent.

Carreras joined United’s academy from Real Madrid in 2020 and showed promise in the Under-23 side, earning loan spells at Preston North End and Granada. Despite flashes of potential, he was never handed a senior debut at Old Trafford.

He later moved permanently to Benfica, where regular first-team football allowed him to flourish. His performances in Portugal quickly attracted attention across Europe.

At Benfica, Carreras became known for his overlapping runs, precise delivery, and defensive composure — attributes that made him one of the most consistent full-backs in the Primeira Liga.

Real Madrid’s scouts reportedly tracked him throughout last season before sanctioning the big-money return.

For Manchester United, Carreras’ success serves as a cautionary tale. With ongoing uncertainty at left-back — following injuries to Luke Shaw and Tyrell Malacia — the Spaniard’s rise is a reminder of the opportunities missed.

Critics argue that had he been given time in the senior setup, United might have developed a long-term solution internally rather than searching the market for alternatives.

Still, Carreras’ journey is testament to his resilience and determination. From academy hopeful to Champions League-level defender, his story reflects the unpredictable nature of player development.

As one United fan posted online: “We let Carreras go for free, and now he’s scoring for Real Madrid — classic United luck.”

While the club moves forward under its new football leadership, the success of Álvaro Carreras will linger as a reminder of the fine margins in youth development — and how quickly potential can become regret.