Amorim verdict: Fans give view on Man Utd boss and if he is right man to turn team around

Ruben Amorim’s arrival at Manchester United last November was met with optimism—a young, tactically astute manager with a Champions League pedigree, tasked with reviving a sleeping giant.

Four months in, with the season at a crossroads, United fans are wrestling with a complex mix of faith, frustration, and cautious hope.

The 3-4-2-1 system, a string of inconsistent results, and whispers of dressing-room unrest have fueled a lively debate.

For many supporters, Amorim’s early tenure—despite its bumps—is a foundation worth building on. A 3-0 league win over Leicester in March and a gritty Europa League campaign have given glimpses of his vision.

On X, @MUFC_Simon posted, “Amorim’s got us playing with structure again—3 at the back suits us, and that Leicester game was class. Patience is key.” The tactical shift to a back three, leveraging players like Matthijs de Ligt and Lisandro Martínez, has won plaudits for its defensive solidity, a rare commodity in recent years.

Fans also point to his Sporting CP success—two league titles and a 71% win rate—as proof of his pedigree.

@RedDevilRants echoed this: “People forget Amorim turned Sporting around in a year. He’s 39, not 60—give him a proper window and watch.” The idea of a long-term project resonates, especially with youth prospects like Chido Obi breaking through under his watch.

After Obi’s debut, @UnitedStandMUFC tweeted, “Amorim trusting the kids is what we’ve begged for. This is the United way.”

Yet, the honeymoon has long faded for a vocal contingent. Six losses in his first 11 games (per The Guardian)—including a dismal Boxing Day defeat to Wolves—left scars.

On X, @UTD_Trey vented, “Amorim’s clueless—3-4-2-1 looks great on paper but we’re still leaking goals and can’t score. Another false dawn.” The stats back up some gripes: United sit mid-table, with an attack misfiring despite Højlund and Zirkzee leading the line.

Criticism often zeros in on his rigidity. @MUFC_Lad_99 wrote, “Amorim’s obsessed with his system—players look lost, and he’s too stubborn to adapt. Ten Hag 2.0.” Reports of squad unrest (United In Focus) amplify this, with leaks suggesting senior players question his methods.

After a limp FA Cup exit, @PogbaRole raged, “Out of the cup, out of ideas—Amorim’s a fraud. Sack him before it’s too late.” For these fans, the Glazers’ track record of managerial missteps looms large, and Amorim risks joining the list.

A third group sits on the fence, weighing potential against reality. @OldTraffordRoar summed it up: “Amorim’s got good ideas—press looks sharper, shape’s better—but we need wins, not promises. Summer’s his make-or-break.”

This pragmatism reflects a fanbase burned by post-Fergie letdowns. The Europa League offers a lifeline—progress there could sway doubters, as @MUFC_Dave noted, “Win that trophy and I’m sold. Lose to Arsenal next month, and I’m done.”

X also buzzes with transfer talk as a litmus test. Fans like @UnitedWeStand99 argue, “Amorim needs his own players—Gyokeres or Osimhen could unlock this team. Judge him after July.” Others, like @RedArmyMUF, counter, “No excuses—Ten Hag got top 4 with worse. Results now or he’s gone.”

Amorim’s approval rating among United fans is a tightrope act. The Leicester win sparked chants of “Ruben’s at the wheel” on X, but a single loss could flip the script. His youth, charisma, and tactical nous inspire hope—yet the Premier League’s unforgiving pace demands instant impact, not just philosophy.

As @MUFCTruth put it, “Amorim’s either our Klopp or our Moyes. Time’s ticking.” With only two league games in March due to the international break, the focus shifts to April’s clashes—Arsenal looms large.

For now, United fans are a house divided: some see a masterplan unfolding, others a rookie out of his depth. One thing’s clear—the X echo chamber will let him know either way.